Skip to main content

Table 1 Accuracy evaluation of ALS point clouds and DEM by reference points

From: Quantification of the spatial distribution of individual mangrove tree species derived from LiDAR point clouds

 

Reference point

ALS

DEM

ALS error (m)

DEM error (m)

Remarks

 

x

y

z

x

y

z

z

Horizontal

Vertical

P1

21,417.7973

 − 181,823.644

2.406

21,415.905

 − 181,824.063

2.494

0.64416

–

–

–

Alongside the bridge structure

P2

21,397.5107

 − 181,826.9974

5.275

21,397.599

 − 181,826.956

5.369

–

0.097523587

0.094

–

Point outside the DEM

P3

21,427.9364

 − 181,819.1984

0.831

21,429.953

 − 181,819.101

0.889

0.81702

–

–

–

Alongside the tree canopy

P4

21,367.2226

 − 181,925.6136

0.326

21,366.405

 − 181,925.666

0.428

0.39588

0.819277438

0.102

0.06988

 

P5

21,468.486

 − 181,796.9861

7.271

21,463.728

 − 181,796.13

7.496

 − 0.3383

–

–

–

On the bridge

P6

21,366.45

 − 181,922.091

0.2929

21,366.472

 − 181,922.054

0.368

0.346

0.043046486

0.0751

0.0531

 

P7

21,463.275

 − 181,796.294

7.31

21,463.259

 − 181,796.339

7.46

 − 0.1786

0.047759816

0.15

–

On the bridge

P8

21,369.714

 − 181,737.606

0.1061

21,369.675

 − 181,737.646

0.101

 − 0.2133

0.055865911

0.0051

0.31938

 

P9

21,406.48

 − 181,805.46

1.9769

21,407.503

 − 181,805.776

2.448

 − 0.1335

–

–

–

Alongside the bridge structure

P10

21,431.488

 − 181,818.516

0.8242

21,431.54

 − 181,818.517

0.881

0.81866

0.052009614

0.0568

0.00554

 

P11

21,480.24

 − 181,833.655

 − 0.0487

21,480.334

 − 181,833.577

 − 0.04

 − 0.0311

0.122147452

0.0087

0.01756

 

P12

21,404.474

 − 181,782.139

0.2773

21,405.116

 − 181,782.225

0.223

0.15956

–

–

–

Under the tree canopy

          

DEM MAE (m)

0.093092

          

DEM RMSE (m)

0.148354612